200 ZFN-Mediated Gene Targeting at the Albumin Locus in Liver Results in Therapeutic Levels of Human FIX in Mice and Non-Human Primates
Hemophilia is an attractive target for gene therapy, since activity levels as low as 1% to 2% of normal are beneficial and levels of ~5% prevent spontaneous bleeding. Our goal was to provide a single treatment that permanently enables hepatic production of therapeutic levels of hFIX activity to decrease or potentially eliminate the need for prophylactic treatment in hemophilia B patients. We performed targeted in vivo genome editing using 1) two zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs) targeting intron 1 of the albumin locus, and 2) a human F9 donor template construct. The ZFNs and donor template are encoded on separate hepatotropic adeno-associated virus serotype 2/6 (AAV2/6) vectors injected intravenously, resulting in targeted insertion of a corrected copy of the hF9 gene into the albumin locus in a proportion of liver hepatocytes. The albumin locus was selected as a “safe harbor” as production of this most abundant plasma protein exceeds 10 g/day, and moderate reductions in those levels are well-tolerated. These genome edited hepatocytes produce normal hFIX in therapeutic quantities, rather than albumin, driven by the highly active albumin enhancer/promoter, to treat hemophilia B; the genetic modification is expected to be sustained even in the face of hepatocyte turnover, making this approach attractive for treating young children with hemophilia before the appearance of significant organ damage. Transformed and primary human hepatocytes transduced in vitro with AAV2/6 encoding human albumin ZFNs and a promoterless hF9 transgene were shown to secrete hFIX. Extensive molecular analyses demonstrated that this was due to targeted integration of the hF9 transgene at the albumin locus and splicing of this gene into the albumin transcript. By employing AAV2/6 delivery of murine-specific ZFNs in vivo, stable levels of hFIX were observed in blood of mice injected with the albumin ZFNs and hF9 transgene donor. C57BL/6 mice were administered vehicle (n=20) or AAV2/6 vectors (n=25) encoding mouse surrogate reagents at 1.0 x1013 vector genome (vg)/kg via tail vein injection. ELISA analysis of plasma hFIX in the treated mice showed peak levels of 50-1053 ng/mL that were sustained for the duration of the 6-month study. Analysis of FIX activity from mouse plasma confirmed bioactivity commensurate with expression levels. Next, we report the feasibility of this approach in non-human primates (NHPs), showing that a single intravenous co-infusion of AAV2/6 vectors encoding the NHP targeted albumin-specific ZFNs and a human F9 donor at 1.2x1013 vg/kg (n=5/group) resulted in >50 ng/mL (>1% of normal) in this large animal model. The use of higher AAV2/6 doses (up to 1.5x1014 vg/kg) yielded plasma hFIX levels up to 1000 ng/ml (or 20% of normal) in several animals and up to 2000 ng/ml (or 50% of normal) in a single animal, for the duration of the study (3 months). The treatment was well tolerated in mice and NHPs, with no significant toxicological findings related to AAV2/6 ZFN + donor treatment in either species at therapeutic doses. Together, these data support a clinical trial to determine if a single co-administration of ZFN and donor AAV vectors is sufficient to enable therapeutic and potentially lifelong production of the clotting factor for the treatment of Hemophilia B.
204 Clinical-Scale Genome Editing of the Human BCL11A Erythroid Enhancer for Treatment of the Hemoglobinopathies
We describe here a fundamentally novel way to develop a disease therapeutic: combining genome-wide association studies (GWAS) with targeted genome editing to create, in a clinically compliant setting, a disease-ameliorating genotype in the patient’s own cells. In β-thalassemia, elevated levels of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) lessen or eliminate disease symptoms, thus making a reversal of HbF silencing in patients an appealing therapeutic strategy. Loss-of-function variants in the erythroid-specific enhancer of the fetal globin repressor, BCL11A, elevate HbF; rare individuals carrying a monoallelic knockout of BCL11A exhibit no known hematologic abnormality and up to 30% circulating HbF. We previously reported de novo knockout of BCL11A using targeted genome editing with engineered zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs) yielding up to 40% HbF in erythroid progeny of edited human CD34 cells in vitro. We now find that the targeted ablation of a single, specific GATAA motif in the BCL11A intronic enhancer does not affect in vitro erythroid differentiation, but reproducibly (n=6) activates fetal globin transcription in erythroid progeny of modified CD34 cells; importantly, at similar levels of on-target marking in CD34+ cells, these effects on fetal globin mRNA are comparable to those resulting from ZFN-driven coding knockout of BCL11A itself. We demonstrate reproducible (n=8), high-efficiency (up to 82%; average, 69%) ZFN-driven marking at the enhancer in peripheral blood mobilized human CD34 cells at clinical production scale (>1e8 cells) in a GMP-compliant setting for which we use a clinical-grade electroporation device to deliver nuclease-encoding transcribed mRNA ex vivo. Using erythroid colony assay genotyping we find that up to 70% of the cells in the resulting population are biallelically modified at the target locus, while ~10% remain wild-type, and find comparably high levels of marking in research-scale preparations of CD34 cells from patients with β-thalassemia. We observe robust long-term (18-24 week) engraftment and multilineage differentiation of genome-edited cells in immunodeficient mice, similar to control cells, and equivalent modification at the targeted enhancer locus at all timepoints in both differentiated (CD19+, CD3+, CD33+) and more primitive progenitor (CD34+CD38low) cells of human origin purified from bone marrow of long-term-engrafted animals. Our findings support clinical development of enhancer editing as a treatment of the β hemoglobinopathies with autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplant.
3234 Clonal Analysis of Human Bone Marrow CD34+ Cells Edited By BCL11A-Targeting Zinc Finger Nucleases Reveals Clinically Relevant Levels of Fetal Globin Expression in Edited Erythroid Progeny
Sickle cell disease (SCD) is one of the most common inherited blood disorders and is caused by a mutation at the adult beta globin gene resulting in substitution of valine for glutamic acid at position 6 in the encoded protein. While SCD can be cured by hematopoietic stem cell transplant (HSCT), complete donor chimerism is not required to achieve clinical benefits. Stable mixed chimerism of 10-15% in bone marrow or peripheral blood nucleated cells with >70% donor-derived RBCs has been reported to achieve transfusion independence and a symptom-free state in a SCD patient. It has also been proposed that SCD can be treated by reactivating developmentally silenced fetal gamma globin to form fetal hemoglobin (alpha2gamma2, HbF), which inhibits polymerization of HbS. The effect of HbF is predicted to be maximal when HbF content per cell exceeds 10 pg (~30% of total Hb). Furthermore, pathology is prevented when protective F cells (>30% HbF per cell) constitute >70% of total RBCs. We hypothesize that in a gene therapy setting, if >15% of SCD patients’ autologous HSCs are programmed to produce protective F cells during erythropoiesis, it will translate into >70% protective F cells in circulation and provide significant alleviation of clinical symptoms. Genome wide association studies have identified BCL11A as a major modifier of HbF levels. Subsequent studies have shown that BCL11A plays a critical role in the fetal to adult globin developmental switch and in repressing fetal globin expression in adult erythroid cells. Conditional inactivation of BCL11A in adult erythroid cells leads to high levels of pan-cellular fetal globin expression and correction of hematologic and pathologic defects in a humanized SCD mouse model. Previously, we have reported that zinc finger nucleases (ZFNs) targeting BCL11A either in the coding region or the GATAA motif in the erythroid-specific enhancer efficiently disrupt the BCL11A locus in human primary CD34+ cells following electroporation of ZFN-encoding mRNA. Elevated fetal globin expression in bulk erythroid cultures was observed following disruption. To determine what percentage of HSPCs have been modified and whether the HbF/F cell content has reached the hypothesized therapeutic level, we analyzed erythroid cells clonally derived from ZFN-transfected CD34+ cells. Genotype of each clonal culture was determined by deep sequencing and globin production was analyzed by a highly sensitive UPLC method. We found that up to 80% of the BFU-Es had both BCL11A alleles edited, half of which had KO/KO alleles (either out of frame mutations for coding region or elimination of the GATAA motif in the enhancer). BCL11A coding KO/KO cells expressed on average 79.1% ± 12.2% fetal globin (Mean ± SD) whereas GATAA motif enhancer region KO/KO cells expressed approximately 48.4% ± 14.1% fetal globin, in comparison with 14.5% ± 9.6% in WT/WT cells . These levels of fetal globin should be sufficiently high to confer protection against HbS polymerization in sickle cells. WT/KO cells in both coding and enhancer editing experiments showed an intermediate phenotype with fetal globin averaging 26.9%± 9.9% and 25.79% ± 12.6%, respectively. Interestingly, when background (WT/WT) fetal globin level was subtracted, the fetal globin levels in WT/KO cells are comparable to those observed in patients with BCL11A haploinsufficiency, which average 14.6%± 10.3%. Together, our data demonstrate that genome editing of BCL11A using highly efficient ZFNs can lead to clinically relevant levels of fetal globin expression in KO/KO erythroid cells. If the frequency of KO/KO BFU-Es we observed in vitro reflects the frequency of KO/KO HSCs in bone marrow after autologous transplantation, genome editing of BCL11A has the potential to provide significant clinical benefit for patients with SCD.
Treatment of neonatal hF9mut mice (harboring the ZFN target site) with 1x1011 vg AAV8-ZFN and 5x1011 vg AAV8-Donor via retro-orbital injection resulted in a drastic difference in hF.IX expression between donors with and without homology 10 weeks post injection (Homology: 1531 ± 174.5 ng/mL vs. No-homology: 146.1 ± 5.8 ng/mL; n=12 and 7, respectively). We next asked whether HDR could be stimulated even more specifically through the induction of DNA single strand breaks at the target site. We treated neonatal mice with homologous or non-homologous donors, as well as ZFNs or ZFNickases (in which one FokI nuclease domain was inactivated with the D450A mutation). ZFNickases were indeed active, resulting in ~250 ng/mL hF.IX 4 weeks post injection (Figure 1). Interestingly, we could not detect hF.IX in mice treated with ZFNickase and no-homology donor (LOD: 15ng/mL). To rule out the possibility that this was simply due to the lower efficacy of ZFNickases compared to ZFNs, we increased the ZFNickase dose 4 fold. Four weeks post treatment, we observed substantial levels of hF.IX in mice treated with homologous donor (2041 ± 269 ng/mL) and were again unable to detect hF.IX in mice treated with the non-homologous donor (n=10 and 7, respectively). These data point to homology directed repair as the primary mechanism of protein production for genome editing in neonatal mouse liver, and suggest improvements in both efficacy and specificity can be made through deeper understanding of the molecular requirements of this approach.
Ablation of Bcl11A could be a viable approach for the treatment of β-hemoglobinopathies such as β-thalassemia and sickle cell disease (SCD), since patients with Bcl11A haploinsufficiency have persistently high levels of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) (up to 30%), which are associated with development of minimal to no disease symptoms. Genome editing by engineered zinc-finger nucleases that target either the exon 2 (exon ZFN) or the GATA motif of the erythroid specific enhancer (enhancer ZFN) of Bcl11A has been shown to increase HbF level in erythroid progeny from mobilized peripheral hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (PB-CD34+ HSPCs). However, peripheral mobilization of CD34+ cells is associated with high risk and currently is not an option for SCD patients. Therefore, we investigated the efficacy of genome editing of Bcl11A in bone marrow derived CD34+ cells (BM-CD34+ HSPCs). We first established a clinically compatible large-scale process to isolate CD34+ HSPCs from human bone marrow aspirates and to transiently express the ZFN protein by mRNA electroporation. The CD34+ isolation process resulted in ~ 95% pure CD34+ cells with greater than 90% viability. Both the exon and the enhancer ZFN drove 50-60% Bcl11A gene editing, resulting in a robust elevation of HbF in the erythroid progeny. Notably, the BM-CD34+ HSPCs were found to contain a small population (10 to 25%) of CD34+CD19+ pro-B cells that were refractory to ZFN transfection under our current electroporation condition. Since CD34+CD19+ pro-B cells are not expected to contribute to reconstituting the hematopoietic system other than B-cell lineage, the Bcl11A editing efficiency in the multipotent BM-CD34+ HSPC could be even higher.
The engraftment abilities of Bcl11A edited BM-CD34+ cells were then investigated in an immunodeficient NOD/scid/gamma (NSG) mouse model. At a dose of 1 million cells per mouse, treatment with either the exon ZFN or the enhancer ZFN did not detectably impact engraftment or multi-lineage reconstitution compared with untreated cells. However, Bcl11A marking in engrafted human cells was found to be markedly higher in the mice treated by the enhancer ZFN than that by the exon ZFN. The exon ZFN resulted in a strong bias towards in-frame mutations across multi-lineages with the strongest effect observed in the B-cell lineage, suggesting that a threshold level of Bcl11A is required for efficient hematopoietic reconstitution and that cells fully lacking it due to disruption of the coding sequence are at a disadvantage. In contrast, the enhancer ZFN resulted in comparable Bcl11A marking across all lineages with no apparent selection for cells with a functional GATA sequence. Collectively, these data indicate that genome editing of the erythroid specific enhancer of Bcl11A in BM-CD34+ promotes HbF reactivation in the erythroid progeny while maintaining the engraftment and multi-lineage repopulating activities of edited BM-CD34+ HSPCs, which supports further clinical development of this approach for the treatment of SCD.
4422 In Vivo Genome Editing in Neonatal Mouse Liver Preferentially Utilizes Homology Directed Repair
Genome editing has the potential to provide long-term therapeutic gene expression in vivo. We have previously demonstrated efficient editing in a mouse model of hemophilia B through liver-directed adeno-associated viral vector (AAV) delivery of a zinc finger nuclease (ZFN) pair and a corrective donor. We determined that homology is not necessary to achieve efficient levels of genome editing in adult mice, consistent with the fact that quiescent cells, including adult hepatocytes, are not thought to be amenable to homology directed repair (HDR). As a consequence of the donor containing a splice acceptor, both HDR and homology independent vector integration are capable of driving human factor 9 (hF.IX) expression. In this study we sought to determine whether hF.IX expression in mice treated as neonates, undergoing substantial hepatocyte proliferation, is predominantly the result of HDR or homology independent genome editing. Provided the efficacy is not substantially reduced, an HDR dependent approach would impose additional constraints on targeting.Treatment of neonatal hF9mut mice (harboring the ZFN target site) with 1x1011 vg AAV8-ZFN and 5x1011 vg AAV8-Donor via retro-orbital injection resulted in a drastic difference in hF.IX expression between donors with and without homology 10 weeks post injection (Homology: 1531 ± 174.5 ng/mL vs. No-homology: 146.1 ± 5.8 ng/mL; n=12 and 7, respectively). We next asked whether HDR could be stimulated even more specifically through the induction of DNA single strand breaks at the target site. We treated neonatal mice with homologous or non-homologous donors, as well as ZFNs or ZFNickases (in which one FokI nuclease domain was inactivated with the D450A mutation). ZFNickases were indeed active, resulting in ~250 ng/mL hF.IX 4 weeks post injection (Figure 1). Interestingly, we could not detect hF.IX in mice treated with ZFNickase and no-homology donor (LOD: 15ng/mL). To rule out the possibility that this was simply due to the lower efficacy of ZFNickases compared to ZFNs, we increased the ZFNickase dose 4 fold. Four weeks post treatment, we observed substantial levels of hF.IX in mice treated with homologous donor (2041 ± 269 ng/mL) and were again unable to detect hF.IX in mice treated with the non-homologous donor (n=10 and 7, respectively). These data point to homology directed repair as the primary mechanism of protein production for genome editing in neonatal mouse liver, and suggest improvements in both efficacy and specificity can be made through deeper understanding of the molecular requirements of this approach.
Ablation of Bcl11A could be a viable approach for the treatment of β-hemoglobinopathies such as β-thalassemia and sickle cell disease (SCD), since patients with Bcl11A haploinsufficiency have persistently high levels of fetal hemoglobin (HbF) (up to 30%), which are associated with development of minimal to no disease symptoms. Genome editing by engineered zinc-finger nucleases that target either the exon 2 (exon ZFN) or the GATA motif of the erythroid specific enhancer (enhancer ZFN) of Bcl11A has been shown to increase HbF level in erythroid progeny from mobilized peripheral hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (PB-CD34+ HSPCs). However, peripheral mobilization of CD34+ cells is associated with high risk and currently is not an option for SCD patients. Therefore, we investigated the efficacy of genome editing of Bcl11A in bone marrow derived CD34+ cells (BM-CD34+ HSPCs). We first established a clinically compatible large-scale process to isolate CD34+ HSPCs from human bone marrow aspirates and to transiently express the ZFN protein by mRNA electroporation. The CD34+ isolation process resulted in ~ 95% pure CD34+ cells with greater than 90% viability. Both the exon and the enhancer ZFN drove 50-60% Bcl11A gene editing, resulting in a robust elevation of HbF in the erythroid progeny. Notably, the BM-CD34+ HSPCs were found to contain a small population (10 to 25%) of CD34+CD19+ pro-B cells that were refractory to ZFN transfection under our current electroporation condition. Since CD34+CD19+ pro-B cells are not expected to contribute to reconstituting the hematopoietic system other than B-cell lineage, the Bcl11A editing efficiency in the multipotent BM-CD34+ HSPC could be even higher.
The engraftment abilities of Bcl11A edited BM-CD34+ cells were then investigated in an immunodeficient NOD/scid/gamma (NSG) mouse model. At a dose of 1 million cells per mouse, treatment with either the exon ZFN or the enhancer ZFN did not detectably impact engraftment or multi-lineage reconstitution compared with untreated cells. However, Bcl11A marking in engrafted human cells was found to be markedly higher in the mice treated by the enhancer ZFN than that by the exon ZFN. The exon ZFN resulted in a strong bias towards in-frame mutations across multi-lineages with the strongest effect observed in the B-cell lineage, suggesting that a threshold level of Bcl11A is required for efficient hematopoietic reconstitution and that cells fully lacking it due to disruption of the coding sequence are at a disadvantage. In contrast, the enhancer ZFN resulted in comparable Bcl11A marking across all lineages with no apparent selection for cells with a functional GATA sequence. Collectively, these data indicate that genome editing of the erythroid specific enhancer of Bcl11A in BM-CD34+ promotes HbF reactivation in the erythroid progeny while maintaining the engraftment and multi-lineage repopulating activities of edited BM-CD34+ HSPCs, which supports further clinical development of this approach for the treatment of SCD.
No comments:
Post a Comment